Five Things The President Will Say Tonight About Afghanistan
White House officials just briefed reporters on President Obama's new strategy for Afghanistan. Here is the top-line takeaway:
1. He plans to increase troop strength in Afghanistan by 30,000 Americans, making the total U.S. troop count 98,000. These forces will be in place by the summer of 2010. A senior administration calls the addition of new troops a "surge." (When Obama came into office, there were 35,000 troops in Afghanistan.)
2. In July of 2011, Obama will "begin transferring" troops out of Afghanistan, but the pace and end date of that withdrawal will depend on conditions on the ground. In other words, while Obama will say that the U.S. military commitment to Afghanistan is not open ended, he will not set an end date for the U.S. military commitment.
3. The goals of the U.S. Afghan campaign remain unchanged: Prevent a Taliban overthrow of Afghan government, and prevent safe haven for Al Qaeda in Afghanistan.
4. The top development goal in Afghanistan will be agriculture. There will also be a major focus on training Afghan troops to take over for the U.S. forces after 2011. But there are no fixed numbers for the end size of the Afghan police and military force.
5. This is an aggressive military approach, according to Obama aides. One senior administration official claimed that the force option Obama chose sends more forces to Afghanistan quicker than any other option presented to him. That said, Obama was presented with other options that called for more total troops to be committed to Afghanistan.
-
1
"The goals of the U.S. Afghan campaign remain unchanged: Prevent a Taliban overthrow of Afghan government, and prevent safe haven for Al Qaeda in Afghanistan."
.
The 9/11 attacks were planned by Saudis in Germany. Al Qaeda doesn't need a "safe haven" in Afghanistan. Besides, they have one next door in nuclear-armed Pakistan.
.
I should also point out that the Taliban are mostly Afghans. Do you think that we should invite in someone's army to make sure that Republicans don't "overthrow" our government any time soon? Come to think of it... -
2
Thanks for a succinct and useful summary.
.
Alas, policy bullet (3) is a guarantee of endless war. Rather than defining an exit strategy, Obama is promising that we will not exit until we can prove two negatives: Al Qaeda no longer exists (since as long as it exists at all, it can conceivably find a safe haven once we leave), and the Taliban no longer exists (since as long as it exists, once we leave it will find enough sympathizers to recoup and pose an eventual realistic takeover threat.)
.
It is impossible to prove a negative. It will therefore prove impossible for Obama to leave Afghanistan, at least until he concocts a more forgiving exit condition than this one.
.
I feel great sympathy for the quandary imposed on Obama by his predecessor, but, in the classical words of Han Solo, "I have a bad feeling about this." -
3
Malalai Joya:
"Like many around the world, I am wondering what kind of 'peace' prize can be awarded to a leader who continues the occupations of Iraq and Afghanistan, and starts a new war in Pakistan, all while supporting Israel?"
Orwell man, Orwell
-
4
Some other things you can expect him to say are: I,I,I.Me,ME,ME Letmebeperfectlyclear. uh, uh, uh....pokiston, tolibon.
Words least likely to be spoken are: War on terror, terrorists, and victory.
-
4.1
I'm sorry, you seem to be reading from the February script. Please see your local Teabagger Team Leader for the latest talking points.
-
-
-
4.4
I would have thought that the parents of serving soldiers would be the last people to treat a decision like this with frivolity.
Maybe twothirds is not convinced they are in fact his children.
-
-
5
senior administration [official] calls the addition of new troops a "surge."
.
according to Obama aides. One senior administration official claimed that"
.
Who told you these things, goddammit? What possible reason could there be to keep these people anonymous? -
6
Prevent a Taliban overthrow of Afghan government, and prevent safe haven for Al Qaeda in Afghanistan.
.
How does this square with reports that the Taliban has a permanent presence in 80% of Afghanistan? -
7
Did he forget to mention the gas pipelines?
http://michaelfury.wordpress.com/2009/05/11/the-gas-must-flow/
-
8
Yes, he said that. And a lot more. It is not open ended, it is not Viet Nam, time has been wasted by the fascists Bushy neocons, we do not seek to dominate the world (unlike the Bushies), and he spoke reason (unlike the Bushies). It was a brilliant speech far beyond the sterile MS prognostication. I am opposed to the Afghan continuation, but he gave me pause for thought and reflection (again, unlike the Bushies).
-
9
After an equivalent length of time, the Soviets were mostly back over the Friendship Bridge and their withdrawal was almost complete.
The US continues to pour in troops, however.
While it is harder for democracies to get into wars (at least until Bush), it is also harder to get out of them. Too many special interests at work.
- michaelscherer Sunday Poem (Dorothea Grossman) "The Two Times I Loves You Most In A Car" http://bit.ly/aZmNWf - 13 hours ago
- michaelscherer RT @markknoller: WH leaking word that S.F. Fed Pres Janet Yellen a leading choice to nominated Vice Chair of the Federal Reserve. - 2 days ago
- michaelscherer RT @ebertchicago: He's one of our new hires. http://j.mp/aDkF9e - 3 days ago
Most Popular »
- Why Does Glenn Beck Hate Jesus?
- HBO's The Pacific: What Fresh Hell
- Catholics Start To Show Their Cards
- The Worst Live-Action Versions of Cartoon Classics
- The Techland Show: The Bitch God Episode
- Is James Cameron About to Piss Off All of Hollywood?
- The Hottest Witches of All-TIME
- 18 Android Apps To Get You Started
- Sneak Peek of Rodriguez's Upcoming Predators Reboot
- The 10 Best Camera Apps for the iPhone
- Holly Graf: Was Female Navy Captain Victim of Sexism?
- Lead Poisoning: Indian Spices Increase Risk in Children
- China's Property: Bubble, Bubble, Toil and Trouble
- Booze, Brawls and Skirt Chasing
- Cell-Phone-Radiation Health Warnings Alarm, Spur Studies
- The Thriving Cult of Greed and Power
- Endangered Species: Why Japan Keeps Fighting the Whale Wars
- Box Office: Alice Turns Damon a Sickly Green
- Calling for New Election, Anti-Government Protesters Swarm Bangkok
- Governor Gone Wild: The Blagojevich Scandal













RSS